What is it?
Feedback is information given to the learner and/or the teacher about the learner’s performance relative to learning goals. It should aim towards (and be capable of producing) improvement in students’ learning. Feedback redirects or refocuses either the teacher’s or the learner’s actions to achieve a goal, by aligning effort and activity with an outcome. It can be about the learning activity itself, about the process of activity, about the student’s management of their learning or self-regulation or (the least effective) about them as individuals. This feedback can be verbal, written, or can be given through tests or via digital technology. It can come from a teacher or someone taking a teaching role, or from peers.
How effective is it?
Feedback studies tend to show very high effects on learning. However, it also has a very high range of effects and some studies show that feedback can have negative effects and make things worse. It is therefore important to understand the potential benefits and the possible limitations of feedback as a teaching and learning approach. In general, research-based approaches that explicitly aim to provide feedback to learners, such as Bloom’s ‘mastery learning’, also tend to have a positive impact. Feedback has effects on all types of learning across all age groups. Research in schools has focused particularly on English, mathematics and, to a lesser extent, science.
Research evidence about feedback was part of the rationale for Assessment for Learning (AfL). One evaluation of AfL indicated an impact of half of a GCSE grade per student per subject is achievable, which would be in line with the wider evidence about feedback.
Other studies reporting lower impact indicate that it is challenging to make feedback work in the classroom. This has also been demonstrated in a recent EEF pilot study where teachers tried to apply the evidence on feedback through an action research approach.
Feedback is widely used as a teaching and learning intervention in schools in Australasia. The few Australasian studies examining the application and impact of feedback on learning in schools are from New Zealand. New Zealand studies on feedback indicate that it impacts positively on learning, students’ ability to give peer feedback, and academic outcomes at primary level.
How secure is the evidence?
There is a substantial number of reviews and meta-analyses of the effects of feedback. Educational (rather than psychological or theoretical) studies tend to identify positive benefits where the aim of feedback is to improve learning outcomes in reading or mathematics or in recall of information. A meta-analysis of studies focusing on formative assessment in schools indicates the gains are more modest, suggesting that an improvement of about three months' additional progress is achievable in schools or nearer four months' when the approach is supported with professional development.
What are the costs?
The costs of providing more effective feedback are not high. However, improving the quality of feedback is likely to require sustained professional development, including active inquiry and evaluation. Estimates of this (including up to 7-10 days cover) are in the region of $5,700 per teacher per year or about $230 per student. Overall, costs are estimated as low.
What should I consider?
Providing effective feedback is challenging. Research suggests that it should be specific, accurate and clear (e.g. “It was good because you...” rather than just “correct”); compare what a learner is doing right now with what they have done wrong before (e.g. “I can see you were focused on improving X as it is much better than last time’s Y…”); encourage and support further effort and be given sparingly so that it is meaningful; provide specific guidance on how to improve and not just tell students when they are wrong; and be supported with effective professional development for teachers.
Broader research suggests that feedback should be about complex or challenging tasks or goals as this is likely to emphasise the importance of effort and perseverance as well as be more valued by the students. Feedback can come from peers as well as adults (see Peer tutoring).
Have you considered the challenge of implementing feedback effectively and consistently?
What professional development is likely to be necessary for successful implementation of feedback in your school?